Troll Lord Games

Rhuvein wrote:Heh, I didn't even know or realize you were using Aihrde. Greyhawk is fine. As a player, I'm less concerned about campaign world as I am concerned about the module being used.

I haven't been very thrilled with about this module, but Kayo - it's not because of you. You are a great CK and thus have probably done more for this module than the author did in creating it. You mentioned it briefly in game, and I have no idea who the author is . . but it's lacking in presentation and excitement.

Anyway, all that said - I'm fine with my character and continuing.

Aramis wrote:Well, I liked the module. But you will be happy to hear that we are now in Greyhawk, so you can choose any module you want. Next stop Barrier Peaks?

Rhuvein wrote:

Aramis wrote:Well, I liked the module. But you will be happy to hear that we are now in Greyhawk, so you can choose any module you want. Next stop Barrier Peaks?

Ooh, so you finished the module? Did the PCs live to tell the tale?

Yep, Barrier Peaks . . or

Isle of APE!

Kayolan wrote:I want to start this in the Wild Coast, with maybe Keep on the Borderlands as a starter. ?!

Kayolan wrote:I want your input on the idea of starting over with new characters or not, if we did, I think that an optional method from the Castle Keeper's Guide might be used for generating attributes, as well as the suggestion in said tome for PCs starting with maximum HP at first level. Would this be too far outside of btb for us to handle?

slimykuotoan wrote:I'm not sure I would want to redo all the modules I've already done.

Aramis wrote:

Kayolan wrote:I want to start this in the Wild Coast, with maybe Keep on the Borderlands as a starter. ?!

Sounds like fun

Kayolan wrote:I want your input on the idea of starting over with new characters or not, if we did, I think that an optional method from the Castle Keeper's Guide might be used for generating attributes, as well as the suggestion in said tome for PCs starting with maximum HP at first level. Would this be too far outside of btb for us to handle?

It's in a book, ain't it?

slimykuotoan wrote:Hmm, I thought we were changing the setting but sticking with our storyline.

Kayolan wrote:

slimykuotoan wrote:I'm not sure I would want to redo all the modules I've already done.

I've never run Keep on the Borderlands before, are you saying you wouldn't have any fun if I ran it?

Aramis wrote:

Kayolan wrote:

slimykuotoan wrote:I'm not sure I would want to redo all the modules I've already done.

I've never run Keep on the Borderlands before, are you saying you wouldn't have any fun if I ran it?

There are many modules to choose from. Which one's are on slimy's Forbidden List?

Hopefully this isn't too big a list

Kayolan wrote:

Aramis wrote:

Kayolan wrote:

slimykuotoan wrote:I'm not sure I would want to redo all the modules I've already done.

I've never run Keep on the Borderlands before, are you saying you wouldn't have any fun if I ran it?

There are many modules to choose from. Which one's are on slimy's Forbidden List?

I'm guessing Keep on the Borderlands is one of them. From what I understand, it's one of the most run modules out there, and after reading through it I can see why. It's a great starting location that can be dropped nearly anywhere and set up for further adventures. I would really like to use it someday.

I think that if we are going to look at this realistically, the chances that any of us haven't been or run through one of these modules is next to nil.

When I do run a module I don't always do so "as is", and I don't use the module in a vacuum.

There is also the possibility of me not using a module, though that would require much more time on my part and I'd like to at least have the option of using something published as an aid in that regard.

Aramis wrote:
Absolutely. You are already working hard running both these games for us. I am fine with almost any of the old school modules.

I have a copy of this but have never read it, I'll look into it tonight...

slimykuotoan wrote:I am pretty bummed because there was no mention of ending this game. You certainly need to run what you enjoy Kayolan, I just need to adjust to this new development.

slimykuotoan wrote:Sorry, I was thinking Keep was a first level module.

slimykuotoan wrote:Then we could go to the next in the series, etc.

Rhuvein wrote:I'm good with Keep or any GH module at low levels (or any of the higher ones, scaled down to low levels - been thinking about doing this lately. Haha, Isle of Ape as mentioned above)!

The thing is, for me anyway ~ B1, B2 or B3 can be run over and over and still be fresh (to a degree anyway), because each CK runs it differently and he/she can completely change anything. Caves of Chaos can use the Blacktooth Ridge dungeons or vice versa. Or, as I will do - design new caves/dungeons/monsters!

The one thing I would prefer, if you're asking Kayo - is that if it's OK with you and the other guys, can we start with 1st level characters?

Haha, you see Kayo - this game and all of our discussion on the boards has got me wanting to run/play an almost btb game at first level.

If I can get anyone interested (via my thread), this is what I'd like to do if I run a game.

Kayolan wrote:

Rhuvein wrote:I'm good with Keep or any GH module at low levels (or any of the higher ones, scaled down to low levels - been thinking about doing this lately. Haha, Isle of Ape as mentioned above)!

The thing is, for me anyway ~ B1, B2 or B3 can be run over and over and still be fresh (to a degree anyway), because each CK runs it differently and he/she can completely change anything. Caves of Chaos can use the Blacktooth Ridge dungeons or vice versa. Or, as I will do - design new caves/dungeons/monsters!

The one thing I would prefer, if you're asking Kayo - is that if it's OK with you and the other guys, can we start with 1st level characters?

Haha, you see Kayo - this game and all of our discussion on the boards has got me wanting to run/play an almost btb game at first level.

If I can get anyone interested (via my thread), this is what I'd like to do if I run a game.

Rhu I think we are pretty much on the same page here. The only change I'd make is to give max HP at first level. If that makes me even 0.01% not btb, then so be it. The version of Keep on the Borderlands I want to run is the 25th anniversary series "Return" version, which takes place 20 years after the original module. It's quite different but yet similar enough to evoke the same feel. Big fan of B3 orange cover, never ran B1 or B2, but am looking forward to it! My idea is to start you guys off as weaklings, then throw in the possibility of Forgotten Temple of Tharizdun, perhaps Barrier Peaks, with some OSR stuff I have along with my own material to blend it together and fill in the empty spaces. I want some gonzo in there too, maybe some Barrier Peaks or something even crazier, like a trip to Blackmoor. As far as 1st level goes, we can vote on it as usual, I don't want to be heavy-handed about it.


Slimy I don't have those modules, but from what I've gleaned, they are not for low level characters and I wouldn't want to run them unless you guys were higher level (after I read through them, I haven't the slightest clue what they are all about actually).

slimykuotoan wrote:Man I would so be interested in Isle of the Ape.

Aramis wrote:I would probably prefer to keep the same characters. We've got a good dynamic going.