Page 2 of 2
Re: How do you have your players roll hit dice?
Posted: Sat Jan 31, 2015 10:02 pm
by Treebore
Hit Points: Max Hp's at first level. d4 HD reroll 1's, d6 and d8 reroll all 1's and 2's, d10 and d12 reroll 1-3's. You can also ask me about "take the CK's roll" before you roll for your HP.
Re: How do you have your players roll hit dice?
Posted: Sat Jan 31, 2015 10:37 pm
by Lord Dynel
Oh, Tree...you're getting soft in your old age.
I've been giving max HP at 1st level, too. But after that, what they roll is what they get. I think playing through some of these hardships is what makes a memorable character later on...if they survive!
If I was playing a truly old-school game (1e, B/X. BECMI, or clones of these), I'd probably make them roll at 1st level, too.
Re: How do you have your players roll hit dice?
Posted: Sun Feb 01, 2015 12:13 am
by Treebore
Lord Dynel wrote:Oh, Tree...you're getting soft in your old age.
I've been giving max HP at 1st level, too. But after that, what they roll is what they get. I think playing through some of these hardships is what makes a memorable character later on...if they survive!
If I was playing a truly old-school game (1e, B/X. BECMI, or clones of these), I'd probably make them roll at 1st level, too.
Nope. Its just very, VERY easy to kill PC's, so I make it a tiny bit easier for me to keep them alive. Ask all my players on this forum. Ask them how many PC's died just a session or two ago, and how many more would have died if not for some judicious use of Dispel Magic, etc... and they are 9th and 10 level. Ask Kayolan, Rigon, Aramis, Gabriel, Lurker, Rhuvein, Rom, and Arrowhawk. Nothing "soft" about me or my games. Brutal is much more accurate.

Re: How do you have your players roll hit dice?
Posted: Sun Feb 01, 2015 12:54 am
by Lord Dynel
Treebore wrote:Lord Dynel wrote:Oh, Tree...you're getting soft in your old age.
I've been giving max HP at 1st level, too. But after that, what they roll is what they get. I think playing through some of these hardships is what makes a memorable character later on...if they survive!
If I was playing a truly old-school game (1e, B/X. BECMI, or clones of these), I'd probably make them roll at 1st level, too.
Nope. Its just very, VERY easy to kill PC's, so I make it a tiny bit easier for me to keep them alive. Ask all my players on this forum. Ask them how many PC's died just a session or two ago, and how many more would have died if not for some judicious use of Dispel Magic, etc... and they are 9th and 10 level. Ask Kayolan, Rigon, Aramis, Gabriel, Lurker, Rhuvein, Rom, and Arrowhawk. Nothing "soft" about me or my games. Brutal is much more accurate.

I was just giving you a hard time, hoss. PCs
are fragile creatures, indeed.